I have learned by hard experience that sometimes a contradiction is not necessarily a bad thing. Sometimes opposing forces balance each other so that neither side overwhelms the other. This is true in many ways. Fear can produce great courage and strength. Great creativity often coincides in a life filled with tragedy. Great love travels well with great loss. The freedoms touted by a democracy can be used to destroy that very democracy. It goes on and on.
I find my own contradiction in being cynical misanthrope who also has great faith. Note I did not say faith in man or in the goodness thereof.
In the cynicism I find I am usually well founded. People are basically selfish and cruel. This hardly needs a soliloquy in its defense. When one comes into contact with a new person you can rest assured they are not on your side and are probably lying. Occasionally I am wrong about someone, I look at that as a pleasant surprise and am thankful for it. It is only in those who have chosen to find their standards in things not of this world and not according to the whims of nature and fashion that you find a real turn for the good. If you see someone who has great faith in man, you will soon see a sorely disappointed individual.
My misanthropy I think comes from my cynicism. Or, perhaps I was born this way. I have just had a deep seated disgust with other people for as long as I can remember. I suspect there are more of us out there than you might think.
For the simple reason that I think man is basically rotten, cruel and dishonest I also expect the best of man. I know men cannot be made angels in this world so I at least expect them to behave. If left to their own devices mankind would quickly descend into anarchy. This is the reason for society and government to exist. The higher standards you hold for someone the better off they, and the society around them are. We can only look around us over the last fifty years to see the cumulative effect of the lowering of standards. You get what you pay for.
In looking back in history I find that I am not alone. From John Adams and Edmund Burke to Tolkein and Updike we see authors and leaders all torn between these seemingly irreconcilable points of view. That is that man is both evil and cruel and yet we must have faith that he can be saved. (Or at least made tolerable enough to live alongside).
I give great credit to the ability to put these ideas into words to Florence King and her works.
Still it is probably best that folks like me are in the minority. We do not share the sunny optimism of most people because we were sent to deal with cold hard reality. In short, we are here to keep it real. Some of us are not so much negative as positive. Positive that faith in the goodness of man is pure naivety. So the next time you down some naysayer who you think is just negative, remember, they may be here to keep your feet on the ground and your friends honest.
von Rum